American Home Shield vs First American Home Warranty
Home warranty comparison — plumbing coverage, costs, and ratings
Our Pick Based on Ratings
American Home Shield wins this comparison
Rating: 4.3/5.0
Our Pick
American Home Shield
4.3/5.0
Monthly$29–$89
Service Fee$100
Covers leaks, stoppages, and water heater repairs. Sewer lines and polybutylene pipes are excluded....
Wide coverage
No age limit on systems
Higher monthly cost
First American Home Warranty
4.2/5.0
Monthly$47–$62
Service Fee$75
Covers plumbing leaks, stoppages, water heater, and toilet mechanisms. Good caps on repairs....
Strong financial backing
Good plumbing caps
Limited customization
Detailed Feature Comparison
| Feature | American Home Shield | First American Home Warranty |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 4.3/5.0 | 4.2/5.0 |
| Monthly Cost (Low) | $29 | $47 |
| Monthly Cost (High) | $89 | $62 |
| Service Call Fee | $100 | $75 |
| Best For | Comprehensive coverage with flexible service fees | Reliable coverage with solid caps |
| Number of Plans | 3 | 2 |